Wild GM Guerin Lacks Trade Chips to Get a Center

Bill Guerin, Kevin Fiala, Paul Fenton, Top Story, Wild Management

One quick look around the Minnesota wilderness will reveal what is a commonly accepted fact in nature and around the NHL: Top-six centers don’t grow on trees. Wild general manager Bill Guerin must now find what does to send back in return, as he reportedly seeks to add depth down the middle. Keep in mind mere foliage likely isn’t to get it done.

Guerin vs. Fenton

Guerin’s predecessor, Paul Fenton, was a mixed bag in that regard. He traded winger Nino Niederreiter for a center in Victor Rask, but, needless to say, that deal didn’t work out as planned. On the other hand, he did also trade away Mikael Granlund, who is a near-top-end top-six center. So, yeah, there’s that.

Paul Fenton Minnesota Wild
Ex-Minnesota Wild GM Paul Fenton – (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

In his defense, on another occasion Fenton acquired Ryan
Donato, who’s shown offensive promise and can play center, but he’s primarily a
winger. Granted, Fenton gave up Charlie Coyle, who has more experience playing
center, to get him, but there’s no use crying about it now. Assuming on the off
chance Donato does eventually work out down the middle, Guerin would still need
at least one more to replace the ones he’s got now.

Staal and Koivu on Their Way Out?

The Wild technically have Eric Staal and Mikko Koivu, but for how long? Koivu is 36 years old with an expiring contract, while Staal is 34. His team-friendly deal, which pays him an average of $3.25 million per season, may be an undeniable asset, but his production took a hit last season. He shouldn’t be anyone’s idea of a long-term solution at center.

Eric Staal, Minnesota Wild
Minnesota Wild forward Eric Staal – (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

Unfortunately, neither Luke Kunin (2016) nor Joel Eriksson
Ek (2015) seem to be either, in spite of their draft pedigrees as former
first-round picks. Granted, they’re just 21 and 22 years old respectively, but,
at best, they are each projects from an offensive standpoint. So, which pieces
can Guerin use? A winger, put simply.

Wild in Holding Pattern on Trade Front

Through the process of elimination, looking from the net out, the NHL goalie market has been historically weak. So, Devan Dubnyk, even if he would be attractive to other teams based on his high level of play and cost-effective deal, likely wouldn’t fetch much. 

The Wild could theoretically get a lot for one of their top defensemen, which is a source of strength. However, Ryan Suter and Jared Spurgeon have no-movement clauses and beyond them and Matt Dumba and Jonas Brodin, there’s not a lot with which to work. So, compromising whatever depth the Wild do have on defense now might not be wise.

Minnesota Wild defenseman Matt Dumba – (Brad Rempel-USA TODAY Sports)

Unfortunately, that sentiment extends to their prospect pool. Former first-round-pick Filip Johansson’s development has stagnated significantly overseas. That leaves the undrafted Brennan Menell as probably their top defensive prospect, which is not meant as a slight, seeing as he’s performed impressively in the American Hockey League. In terms of appeal, the Wild may have a hard time selling a potential trade partner on a 5-foot-11, 172-pound defenseman with zero NHL experience. He could realistically pan out, but whatever NHL career he ends up having will likely be with the Wild, at least to start.

Up front, left-winger Kirill Kaprizov is one of the best NHL prospects playing outside of North America. He has a year left on his Kontinental Hockey League contract though and his rights likely wouldn’t yield as much as Guerin would hope. That leaves Matthew Boldy, in whom the Wild have high hopes. Seeing as the Wild just drafted him, they probably wouldn’t want to trade him until they get a better idea of what they have in the prospect, who plays the left side too and projects as an elite two-way forward.

Zucker vs. Fiala

That really just leaves whoever’s on the roster up front, including the usual suspects like Jason Zucker. During Fenton’s tenure, Zucker’s name was all over the rumor mill. Look for that trend to continue, even though trading a proven 20-goal scorer on a decent deal may come back to bite Guerin. Zucker’s also 27 going on 28. While that means Zucker’s in his prime, it also means he’s likely peaked and may not be as attractive, as, say 23-year-old Kevin Fiala.

Current-Minnesota Wild forward Kevin Fiala – (Christopher Hanewinckel-USA TODAY Sports)

Fiala’s shown offensive flare, is a former first-round pick (2014), and is young enough that teams may be willing to invest in his future by sending an established center back the Wild’s way. Kinda like how Fenton did the exact same thing for Granlund. Good times.

It might be seen as a step backwards, especially if Guerin would have to add on a draft pick to get something done. However, give Fenton some credit here in the sense that it wasn’t working with the players he had. Fenton had to do something. It just turns out he did the wrong things time and again. Even if Guerin has to undo some of the damage done, he can theoretically acquire the right players in the process this time around.

Fiala can still be a key component for the Wild. However, if it means getting back a sorely needed center, he’ll have to be a key component in a trade instead. He’s probably the best and biggest trade chip the Wild have, which isn’t as ominous as it may sound. After all, Guerin has it right when he sees a center as being his biggest need.

Craig Leipold Minnesota Wild Bill Guerin
Bill Guerin and Minnesota Wild owner Craig Leipold – (Photo by Bruce Kluckhohn/NHLI via Getty Images)

Even if he can’t realistically trade a defenseman or goalie,
the Wild are effectively a top-10 team in terms of shots and goals against.
Their organizational depth chart may be lacking in terms of prospects at those
positions, but at least they’ve got the right players in place now. Fixing the
offense is the ticket. Getting a center could do the trick and get the Wild
back into the playoffs. Admittedly easier said than done, but at least Guerin knows
what needs to be done. Fenton was lost. That’s already a step in the right
direction out of the woods.

Products You May Like

Articles You May Like

First Black man in the NHL, Willie O’Ree pained by racism in society, hockey
NHL Rumors: Taylor Hall and Henrik Lundqvist
NHL Rumors: Ilya Sorokin, Kirill Kaprizov, Los Angeles Kings, and the Anaheim Ducks
The NHL’s coronavirus pause: Players, coaches offer opinions on return-to-play format
Survey finds Canadian NHL fans OK if country doesn’t host playoff games

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *